Free tool
Trees and yards
Tree service quote comparison checklist
Compare up to three tree service quotes side by side: insurance, cleanup, stump, reviews and deposit.
Open the tool: Tree service quote comparison checklistFor homeowners
Stump removal options: grind it, dig it out or leave it
The tree is gone, but the stump is still there. You have three real choices. This guide explains each one, what to expect on the day, and what to ask a local pro. We do not list prices. Get two or three written quotes.
By Umair Nawaz, founder of Lirevon Updated How we check facts
The three options
The best choice depends on what you want that spot to become: lawn, garden, a new tree, a patio, or nothing at all.
Stump grinding
A machine with a spinning, toothed wheel chews the stump into chips, down to a set depth below the soil. The main roots stay in the ground and rot slowly. It is the most common choice because it is fast and leaves the yard mostly flat, plus a pile of chips and soil.
Full stump removal
The crew digs out the stump and the large roots near it, often with a machine. It leaves a bigger hole to fill with soil and disturbs more of the yard, but it clears the spot more fully. People often choose it before building, paving or replanting in the same place.
Leaving the stump
You can simply keep the stump, cut low to rot away, or use it as a seat or plant stand. It needs no extra work today. The trade-offs: a trip hazard, mowing trouble, new shoots on some kinds of trees, and insects or fungi as it decays.
Side-by-side table
A quick comparison. Your yard may differ, so ask a pro who has seen the stump.
| Grinding | Full removal | Leave it | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What happens | Stump is ground into chips below the soil | Stump and big roots are dug out | Stump stays, often cut low |
| Roots | Stay in the ground and rot slowly | Main roots near the stump come out | All stay |
| Yard disturbance | Small to moderate | Larger: a real hole to fill | None today |
| Debris | A pile of chips and soil | Stump, roots and soil to haul | None |
| Replant in the same spot? | Possible, but ask about depth and chips | Usually easier | No |
| Build or pave there? | Ask a pro; roots will decay and soil may settle | Usually the better fit | No |
| Watch out for | Hidden pipes, wires and rocks; flying debris | Utility lines, foundations, soil settling | Trip hazard, sprouts, insects |
| Cost | Get two or three written quotes | Get two or three written quotes | No extra work today |
On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see all columns.
How to choose
Start with your plan for the spot. Then match it to an option.
- You want to mow over the spot and plant grass: grinding is usually enough.
- You want a new tree in the same spot: ask about full removal or a deeper grind, with fresh soil.
- You plan a patio, shed or driveway there: ask about full removal and settling soil.
- The stump is close to a house, fence or buried lines: ask which method is safer there.
- You like the stump, or the spot sees little traffic: leaving it can be fair.
- Not sure: ask two or three local pros what they would do and why.
If the tree is still standing, settle the stump choice in the removal quote. See what changes the cost of tree removal.
What to expect on the day
A little planning makes the visit smoother and safer.
- Before the visit, mark sprinkler heads, yard lighting, pet fences and any buried lines you know about. In the US, call 811 before any digging so public utility lines can be marked. Ask who makes the call.
- A stump grinder needs a path to the stump. Measure your gate and mention slopes, soft ground and septic areas.
- Grinding is loud and throws chips and small stones. Keep kids and pets inside, and move cars and furniture away.
- Afterward there is a mound of chips and soil. Some quotes include raking, hauling or filling the hole; others leave the chips for you to use as mulch.
- Surface roots along the lawn are not always included. Say so if you want them ground too.
- Over the next months the spot can sink a little as roots break down. Adding topsoil and seed is normal.
Questions to ask: a short checklist
Ask every company the same questions, so you can compare quotes for the same work.
Is the stump included in the tree removal quote?
Many removal quotes leave it out.
Do you grind, dig it out, or both?
Know which method you are paying for.
How deep below the ground will you grind?
Depth matters if you want to replant or lay sod.
Are surface roots included?
They are a common surprise later.
What happens to the chips and the hole?
Left, raked, hauled or filled with soil: each is a different job.
Who calls 811 to mark utility lines?
Someone must, before any digging.
How will you protect my house, windows, fence and lawn?
Ask about screens for flying debris.
Are you insured, and can I see the certificate?
Ask for liability and workers compensation, and check both are current.
More help: how to hire a tree service and the full list of questions to ask. If you are not sure whether a nearby tree is safe, read is my tree dangerous?
Safety first
The machines are powerful and the ground can hide lines and pipes.
- Leave grinding and digging to a trained, insured pro. Call 811 before any digging.
- Stay away from power lines. If a line is down or a tree is on a line, call your utility. If anyone is in danger, call 911.
- Do not use a chainsaw on storm-damaged or bent wood, including a broken trunk still on the stump. It can hold hidden tension and spring back with great force.
- Keep children and pets well back while a grinder runs, and until the hole is filled.
After a storm, read what to do after a storm. Back to the homeowner guides.
Common questions
What is the difference between stump grinding and stump removal?
Grinding chews the stump into chips below the ground and leaves the roots to rot. Removal digs out the stump and large roots, leaving a bigger hole to fill. Ask which one a company means.
How much does stump grinding cost?
We do not list prices for tree work. The size of the stump, the number of stumps, access, roots and cleanup all change the price. Get two or three written quotes from local, insured pros for the same scope.
Is it okay to just leave a stump?
Often, yes. A stump can rot away on its own over the years. Watch for trip hazards, new shoots, and insects or fungi as it decays.
Will the stump grow back?
Some kinds of trees send up shoots from the stump or roots. Grinding usually stops most of this, but a few sprouts can appear.
Can I plant a new tree where the old stump was?
Often, but it is easier after full removal or a deeper grind, with the chips cleared and fresh soil added. Many people plant a little to one side instead.
Do I need to call 811 before stump grinding?
In the US, 811 is the free call-before-you-dig number, and digging or deep grinding near buried lines is risky. Ask the company who will make the call. Short explanation, not legal advice.
Should I rent a stump grinder and do it myself?
We suggest leaving it to a trained, insured pro. Grinders throw debris, can hit buried lines and are hard to control. Never use a chainsaw on storm-damaged wood or cut near power lines.
Can I burn a stump or use chemicals?
Burning is often restricted by local rules and can be a fire risk. Chemicals can harm plants, pets and soil. Ask a pro first. Short explanation, not legal advice.
Does homeowners insurance pay for stump removal?
It depends on your policy and what happened to the tree. Call your insurance company and read your policy. Short explanation, not insurance advice.
Does Lirevon grind stumps or recommend companies?
No. Lirevon does not do tree work and does not list or rank tree companies. We help tree service owners run their business. This guide is general information for homeowners.
Keep reading: the stump grinding vs stump removal comparison, does tree removal include the stump, what stump grinding means, and our tree species guides (some trees sprout again).
This page is general information, not legal or insurance advice. We do not give prices for tree work; get two or three written quotes from local, insured pros.
Next step: find a local pro
Find local pros on Google Maps and read their reviews. Lirevon does not list, rank or get paid by any tree company.
Own a tree service?
Lirevon helps tree service owners answer every call and win more jobs. See how we help.